Imagine Maya, bright, eager, fresh from her studies. She walked into “InnovateCorp” buzzing with the kind of energy that could power a small city. Their website, a symphony of inspiring stock photos and bold pronouncements, sang of “Integrity, Collaboration, Impact!” These weren’t just words to Maya; they were a promise. Six months later, that promise felt like a forgotten tune from a half-remembered dream. “Integrity” was a word that seemed to evaporate whenever quarterly reports were due. “Collaboration” often translated to enduring the monologue of the most senior person in the room. And “Impact”? The only impact Maya registered was the dull thud of her own spirits hitting rock bottom. She’d heard the values, once, during a whirlwind orientation day, a fleeting mention before the deep dive into software protocols and HR policies. Then, silence.
~Listen to the audio review of this article
Maya isn’t a fictional outlier. She’s the voice of a generation. Consider this: a striking 75% of Gen Z workers say they would willingly take a pay cut to work for a company that genuinely aligns with their personal values. For many, when the values proudly displayed on the corporate banner are treated as little more than decorative wallpaper, their own sense of purpose begins to fray. It’s not just about a bad day or a tough project; it’s a deeper, more existential ache. This isn’t merely a Gen Z phenomenon, though they might be its most vocal exponents. It’s a human one. When the place we dedicate a vast chunk of our lives to feels devoid of genuine, lived values, a peculiar kind of emptiness can set in.
This isn’t a new problem, though its modern guise is particularly acute. Over a century ago, the sociologist Émile Durkheim put a name to a similar societal malaise: anomie. Think of it as a state of normlessness, a societal vertigo where the old rules and guiding principles have crumbled, leaving individuals adrift, unsure of their footing or their direction. [1, 2] Durkheim saw it in the societal upheavals of industrialization, where economic pursuits became unmoored from a broader moral compass. [1] Today, we see its shadow in organizations where the relentless pursuit of metrics, or sheer institutional inertia, allows stated values to become hollow echoes.
So, what are these “values” we’re talking about? They’re far more than just pleasant-sounding words or ethical guidelines scribbled in a handbook. Values, in the context of a flourishing human environment, are the very framework upon which positive human thriving is built. They are the lived, breathed, and consistently demonstrated principles that cultivate an atmosphere of trust, meaning, and shared purpose. They are the invisible currents that, when flowing strongly, energize individuals and bind teams together. When these currents weaken or vanish, the ecosystem begins to wither.
The Downward Spiral: When Values Fade and Anomie Takes Hold
Durkheim’s anomie wasn’t just an abstract sociological concept; it described a painful human reality: a sense of disconnection, aimlessness, and a gnawing feeling that life lacks a coherent purpose. [2, 3] Translate this to the modern workplace. When an organization’s proclaimed values are just words on a page, discussed once at orientation and then seemingly forgotten, a subtle but corrosive anomie begins to permeate the culture. [4, 5]
Employees, like Maya, find themselves in a kind of limbo. What’s truly expected? What’s genuinely rewarded? Is it the collaborative spirit mentioned in the mission statement, or the sharp-elbowed competitiveness that seems to win promotions? This ambiguity isn’t just confusing; it’s deeply unsettling. Trust begins to erode – trust in leadership, trust in the system, sometimes even trust in colleagues. [3, 6] A “subculture of excuses,” as one researcher termed it, can emerge, where deviations from stated norms become rationalized, a collective shrug in the face of perceived hypocrisy. [4]
The psychological toll is significant. Work, which for many is a primary source of identity and purpose, can start to feel meaningless. [6] That initial spark of energy and motivation dims, replaced by a kind of weary resignation. It’s not laziness; it’s a natural human response to an environment that feels fundamentally misaligned. Studies show that a significant percentage of people feel a lack of energy when a core, shared value is missing from their work lives. [7] This isn’t just about feeling “off”; it can manifest in more serious ways. Prolonged exposure to such an environment can contribute to stress, anxiety, and even depression. [6] The much-discussed phenomenon of burnout isn’t just about overwork; it’s often intertwined with this deeper crisis of meaning and value-disconnect. [8, 9] Hope dwindles, drive fades. The desire to contribute, to build, to achieve, gets lost in the fog of an anomic workplace.
The behavioral consequences are just as stark. Disengagement becomes rampant. If the values don’t matter, why should I? Productivity dips, not out of malice, but because the intrinsic motivation has been starved. [6, 9] People start looking for exits, contributing to the high turnover rates that plague many industries. [7] In more extreme cases, when the lines of what’s acceptable become blurred, the door can even open to less ethical behaviors. [4, 6] It’s a grim picture, but one that’s all too common when the value infrastructure of an organization is allowed to decay.
The Antidote: Weaving Values into the Fabric of Work
If the absence of lived values is a path to anomie and disengagement, then the cultivation of authentic, deeply embedded values is the pathway back to thriving. But how do we understand what makes certain values resonate so powerfully?
Social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, in his work on Moral Foundations Theory, offers a fascinating perspective. He suggests that our minds come equipped with a set of foundational “value receptors,” akin to taste buds on our tongue. These foundations – which he identifies as Care/Harm, Fairness/Cheating, Loyalty/Betrayal, Authority/Subversion, Sanctity/Degradation, and Liberty/Oppression – are the evolved psychological mechanisms through which we intuitively grasp and respond to our social world. Different cultures, and indeed different individuals, might emphasize these foundations to varying degrees, like adjusting the sliders on an audio equalizer. But they represent a universal palette of human values.
When a workplace culture consistently and authentically activates these positive value receptors – when people feel cared for, treated fairly, part of a loyal team, respectful of just authority, engaged in something pure or meaningful, and free from oppression – it creates a profound sense of “rightness.” It’s not just about following rules; it’s about tapping into these deep-seated intuitions about what constitutes a good, trustworthy, and motivating environment. Haidt speaks of “moral capital” – the resources like shared values, virtues, and norms that enable a community to flourish by regulating selfishness and fostering cooperation. A workplace rich in this moral capital, built on lived values, is inherently more resilient and conducive to well-being.
This is where the concept of “values on the wall” versus “values in action” becomes critical. For values to be the antidote to anomie, they can’t just be aspirational statements. They need to be the very lifeblood of the organization, evident in every decision, every interaction, every system. [7] Think of a principle like “valuing people.” If this is a core value, it should be visible in how meetings are run, how feedback is given, how promotions are decided, and how mistakes are handled. [7]
When an organization succeeds in this, something powerful happens: value congruence. This is the sweet spot where an individual’s personal values align with the values demonstrated by their workplace. [10] It’s like finding a key that fits a lock perfectly. Suddenly, work isn’t just a place you go to earn a paycheck; it becomes an extension of who you are, a place where you can express your deepest principles. [11] The impact is transformative. Energy levels surge. Commitment deepens. People find a genuine reason to care, to pour their discretionary effort into their tasks, because they feel they are part of something meaningful. [11] Indeed, a vast majority of employees today state that having a purpose-driven job is pivotal to their overall well-being and satisfaction.
This isn’t just about feeling good, though that’s a crucial part of it. It’s about unlocking human potential. When values are lived, and when individuals feel that congruence, we see a dramatic uptick in engagement, a renewed sense of hope, and a powerful drive to contribute. [12, 11] Mental well-being improves, not because problems disappear, but because individuals feel anchored, supported, and part of a coherent, principled environment. [9, 10] And, not surprisingly, people are far less likely to leave. Why would you abandon a place where you feel genuinely valued and aligned? [13]
Leadership: The Living Embodiment of Values
If values are the architecture of a thriving workplace, then leaders are its chief architects and, perhaps more importantly, its most visible inhabitants. The authenticity of an organization’s values begins and ends with its leadership. [14] Employees, with their finely tuned hypocrisy detectors, look to leaders to see what really matters. Are the proclaimed values just for show, or are they the genuine compass guiding decisions, especially the tough ones?
Leaders who authentically embody the organization’s values create a ripple effect. Their consistency builds trust. Their commitment fosters psychological safety – that crucial sense that it’s okay to speak up, to be vulnerable, to admit mistakes without fear of retribution. [9, 10] This safety is the bedrock upon which a truly value-driven culture can be built. It’s in these environments that employees feel empowered, not just to follow values, but to champion them, to question when things seem off-kilter, and to contribute to a culture of shared purpose. [10, 13]
This isn’t about leaders being perfect. It’s about them being genuine, transparent, and consistently striving to align their actions with the shared principles of the organization. It’s about fostering open dialogue around values, making them a living conversation rather than a static edict. [11, 15]
A System for Thriving: Beyond Good Intentions
Recognizing the importance of values is the first step. But how does an organization move from well-intentioned statements to a deeply embedded, thriving, value-driven culture? It requires more than just hope; it demands a systematic approach.
This is where the work of organizations like VP Culture becomes so vital. They understand that building a culture where positive human thriving is the norm isn’t accidental. It requires a robust understanding of what values truly are, how they connect to fundamental human needs (as illuminated by thinkers like Haidt), and how they can be woven into the daily fabric of organizational life. VP Culture provides a system – complete with comprehensive understanding, detailed discussions, and practical applications – designed to help organizations build this kind of environment. [7, 12] It’s about moving beyond the “values on the wall” and creating a dynamic, living ecosystem where values like trust, harmony, peace, wisdom, nobility, and joy aren’t just ideals, but experienced realities that foster individual and collective flourishing. [12]
The Path Forward: Cultivating Workplaces of Meaning
The Mayas of the world are sending a clear message. They, like all of us, crave work that is more than just a transaction. They seek environments where they can connect with a larger purpose, where their contributions feel meaningful, and where the stated values of the organization are reflected in the everyday reality of their working lives.
The challenge of workplace anomie is real, and its costs – to individuals and organizations – are immense. But the solution isn’t a mystery. It lies in a conscious, deliberate, and sustained commitment to building cultures grounded in authentic, lived values. It requires understanding that values are not soft, optional extras, but the fundamental building blocks of human thriving. By embracing a robust framework for understanding and implementing values, by ensuring leaders are their living embodiment, and by making values an ongoing, dynamic conversation, organizations can transform themselves. They can become places where energy is unleashed, where purpose is clear, where hope is rekindled, and where every individual has the opportunity not just to work, but to truly thrive. This isn’t just good for business; it’s good for humanity.
Works cited
- Anomie Theory | Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology, accessed May 15, 2025, https://oxfordre.com/criminology/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264079-e-244?p=emailA8QwzhuJMpwA6&d=/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264079.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264079-e-244
- DURKHEIM’S LEGACY: ANOMIE’S IMPACT ON CAPITALISM’S UNFOLDING – Jus Scriptum Law, accessed May 15, 2025, https://www.jusscriptumlaw.com/post/durkheim-s-legacy-anomie-s-impact-on-capitalism-s-unfolding
- Revisiting the Measurement of Anomie – PMC, accessed May 15, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4934700/
- ejournals.eu, accessed May 15, 2025, https://ejournals.eu/en/journal_article_files/full_text/018eced9-8bf3-7252-9b29-cf1886466147/download
- WOrk ANOmiE iN AN OrgANiSATiON, accessed May 15, 2025, https://ejournals.eu/pliki_artykulu_czasopisma/pelny_tekst/0efb8961-d9f8-4d00-8dd3-77bd942e850c/pobierz
- centerprode.com, accessed May 15, 2025, https://centerprode.com/ojer/ojer0502/coas.ojer.0502.04161a.pdf
- Springfield VP Culture Creation School, accessed May 15, 2025, https://vpculture.com/springfield-school-of-leadership-and-culture/
- Situations of anomie and the health workforce crisis: Policy implications of a socially sensitive and inclusive approach to human resources – PubMed, accessed May 15, 2025, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38358841/
- Full article: Fostering employee engagement and mental health: Impact of psychological safety, humble leadership, and knowledge sharing in the Japanese public sector – Taylor & Francis Online, accessed May 15, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/12294659.2025.2463135
- Relationships Among Organizational Values, Employee …, accessed May 15, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7010974/
- The impact of values on organizational success – MGMA, accessed May 15, 2025, https://www.mgma.com/articles/the-impact-of-values-on-organizational-success
- Articles from VP Culture – VP Culture, accessed May 15, 2025, https://vpculture.com/articles-from-vp-culture/
- The search for ‘meaning’ at work – BBC, accessed May 15, 2025, https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220902-the-search-for-meaning-at-work
- Relationship between Organizational Culture, Leadership Behavior …, accessed May 15, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3123547/
- How to Put Core Values Into Practice: 4 Actionable Steps – Connective Web Design, accessed May 15, 2025, https://connectivewebdesign.com/blog/how-to-put-core-values-into-practice
- Gen Z and the Workplace: What It Means to Be Part of The Anxious Generation – here* | Mental Health Training & Advocacy, accessed May 26, 2025, https://changeishere.co/mental-wellness-blog/the-anxious-generation
- The Righteous Mind – Wikipedia, accessed May 26, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Righteous_Mind
- Moral Foundations Theory Explained by Jonathan Haidt – Divided We Fall, accessed May 26, 2025, https://dividedwefall.org/the-righteous-mind-moral-foundations-theory/
- Moral Foundation Theory and the Law – Seattle University School of …, accessed May 26, 2025, https://digitalcommons.law.seattleu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1018&context=sulr
- Jonathan Haidt’s “The Righteous Mind” – good people divided by …, accessed May 26, 2025, https://pnhp.org/news/jonathan-haidts-the-righteous-mind-good-people-divided-by-politics/
The Gen Z Effect and the Workforce Evolution: 2024 Statistics, accessed May 26, 2025, https://cake.com/empowered-team/gen-z-workforce-statistics/